Other Links
« The Committee Got Nowhere- No Surprise! | Main | The Gang Returns Today And China Is On their Mind »

Is Tom Mulcair Right?

Back on February 4th Tom Mulcair was speculating that some NDP supporters might think the Green Party deserved a second look.

It is an interesting thought. Should it happen, it could seriously damage the election chances of the NDP, and it has the potential to damage the Liberals as well.

The NDP is in bad shape- they have come off of their worse fundraising quarter, their leader is struggling to be relevant and they keep sending mixed policy messages such as on Venezuela.

In the mean time the Greens are on a roll, at least at the provincial level. They elected three members in New Brunswick, one in Ontario and may have a chance in PEI. Plus, the federal party has just had its best fundraising quarter ever.

So called “progressives” (really who invents these terms) have the choice of backing Trudeau who has failed on almost every issue that is dear to them. From double-crossing them on proportional representation; to lots of flash, but little substance on environmental issues; to killing one pipeline only to then buy another one and the list goes on.

NDP supporters, especially those who are strong on the environment could easily go to the Green Party.

Other NDPers who worry about a Conservative win, may feel they have no choice but to hold their nose and support Trudeau. Either way the NDP pays a price.

As for the two main stream federal parties, they need to wake up and smell the coffee too. Voters are tired of the same old policies and lack of vision. They are tired of the daily antics they see from both sides. They are tired of the name calling and mudslinging.

Just look at the last election in Quebec where the voters gave both of the main stream provincial parties, the PQ and the Liberal Party, a wake-up call by electing the CAQ.

So far, the Greens have never really convinced federal voters that they have more to offer than their stance on environmental issues. But they do appeal to younger voters which is a growing demographic.

Most voters, young or old, would be surprised to know that the Green policy platform, excluding photos, only has 4 pages on the environment out of a total of 44 pages. There is lots in there on a national senior’s program, the CPP, reducing red tape for small business, supporting the manufacturing sector, pharmacare, eliminating student debt etc.

If they ever figure out how to communicate their platform better, they could become a force to be reckoned with. That is bad news for the NDP, and it should be a wake-up call for both the Conservatives and the Liberals.

Was Mulcair just causing a bit of trouble by trying to get even with the party that dumped him as leader,  or is he on to something? The next election will tell if he was right.

Reader Comments (3)

all the country needs is more hard core socialists. These green bleaters are worse than the NDP by a factor of 10.

February 8, 2019 | Unregistered Commenterold white guy

These are fair assessments.
But there is one factor to be considered.
For the last three elections since she has been leader of the Green party, Elizabeth May has shown a noticeable lack of enthusiasm when it comes to attacking the liberal party, even to the point of having the appearance of being Justin Trudeau's cheerleader.
To factor that in May will under the scenario you have laid out, have to demonstrate that she will attack Trudeau just as viscerally as she did Stephen Harper. Any lack of enthusiasm will be seen as weakness from the disenchanted.

February 8, 2019 | Unregistered CommenterJoseph

You are quite right. She was successful in laying the groundwork for the party but has been unsuccessful in moving the federal party further forward than it is and part of that is the point you just raised. Far too cozy with the Liberals. The party needs a leader who is focused on victory and not on cozy relations. If she finds that focus and puts the right team around her, it will be an interesting election.

February 9, 2019 | Unregistered Commenteratory

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>